AI Tools Could Hinder Learning by Inducing Cognitive Debt

A recent study published on arXiv explores the neural and behavioral effects of using large language models (LLMs), like ChatGPT, for essay writing. It identifies a phenomenon termed “cognitive debt,” which may negatively impact learning and critical thinking. Involving 54 participants, the study divided them into three groups: LLM users, search engine users, and a control group relying solely on their cognitive resources. Electroencephalography (EEG) findings showed that the “Brain-only” group exhibited greater neural connectivity, suggesting deeper cognitive engagement, while LLM users displayed reduced brain activity, indicating a reliance on AI for cognitive tasks. Although LLM-assisted essays rated well in consistency, they often lacked the creativity of those produced without AI. This raises concerns about over-reliance leading to atrophy in critical thinking skills. The research advocates for balanced AI integration in education and work, emphasizing the need to nurture independent thought alongside technology.

Source link